The sun streams through floor-to-ceiling windows at Riverview Brewing as James Miller checks fermentation temperatures on his newest batch. Six years after founding this operation, his meticulous approach to brewing has earned recognition throughout the region. Every production detail is tracked in detailed spreadsheets – fermentation temperatures, grain bills, hop additions timed to the minute.
"In production, we measure everything," James explains, scrolling through pages of brewing logs on his tablet. "But when it comes to understanding our business growth, things get surprisingly foggy."
This contrast represents a fascinating paradox within the craft beverage industry – extreme precision in production processes alongside remarkable uncertainty in business intelligence.
Craft brewers and distillers typically operate within two distinct paradigms. In production, precision reigns supreme. Ingredient measurements accurate to the gram, temperature controls monitored to the degree, and detailed documentation of every production variable are industry standards. This scientific approach ensures consistency and quality.
"The production side has always been data-driven," explains Dr. Hannah Chen, who studies operational systems in small-scale manufacturing. "These producers essentially run small chemistry labs. Measurement is fundamental to their craft."
Yet paradoxically, many of these same meticulously detailed producers operate with remarkably little data about fundamental business questions: Which products generate the most profit? Which investments yield the strongest returns? Which customer segments drive sustainable growth?
"It's a fascinating cognitive dissonance," notes Chen. "The same person who would reject a batch that's half a degree off temperature target might make major business decisions based primarily on intuition."
The roots of this measurement paradox lie partly in the industry's history and culture. Many craft producers enter the field through passion for the product rather than business expertise.
"I studied fermentation science and worked in production for years before opening my own place," says Teresa Martinez, founder of Westridge Distillery in Colorado. "My background gave me excellent skills for making quality spirits but very little training in business analytics."
The production-first mentality persists even as businesses grow. While a craft producer might invest tens of thousands in specialized equipment to improve product quality marginally, they often operate with rudimentary systems for tracking basic business metrics.
This imbalance creates what industry economist Michael Rivera calls "selective empiricism" – the application of rigorous measurement standards to some aspects of the business while relying on intuition for others.
The consequences of this measurement gap become increasingly significant as businesses mature. Without comprehensive data, decision-making suffers from invisible biases and missed opportunities.
At Clearwater Distilling, production manager Alicia Gomez noticed this problem when analyzing their special releases. "We were deciding which products to scale up based mostly on what generated excitement among staff and enthusiasts. When we finally implemented proper financial tracking, we discovered our limited-edition whiskeys – despite their prestige – were significantly less profitable than our standard gin line. We'd been making business decisions based on perception rather than performance."
Beyond product decisions, the measurement gap affects virtually every aspect of business planning, from staffing to expansion strategies. Without clear data connecting business activities to outcomes, craft producers struggle to allocate resources effectively.
"The irony," notes Rivera, "is that these businesses often have incredibly tight margins. They literally cannot afford to make decisions based on incomplete information, yet many do exactly that."
This measurement paradox isn't unique to craft beverages. Economic historians point to similar patterns in other industries during their artisanal-to-professional transitions.
Dr. Lawrence Meeks, who studies business evolution patterns at Cornell University, sees clear parallels with early 20th-century manufacturing.
"Before Frederick Taylor's scientific management principles, many factories combined advanced production techniques with remarkably primitive business operations. They knew precisely how to make products but operated with much less precision in understanding costs, efficiency, and profitability."
This historical perspective suggests the craft beverage industry may be experiencing a natural evolutionary stage as it matures from passion-driven startups to sustainable businesses.
Some craft producers have begun addressing this imbalance by applying the same empirical mindset to business operations that they've always used in production.
At Oakmont Brewing in Pennsylvania, head brewer Sam Wilson implemented a comprehensive data collection system after recognizing the paradox in his own operation.
"I realized I could tell you exactly how many kilograms of Citra hops went into last Tuesday's batch, but I couldn't tell you which of our five distribution channels was most profitable. That disconnect was ultimately unsustainable."
Wilson's system now tracks key performance indicators across the business with the same rigor applied to production metrics. "We measure margin by product, profitability by distribution channel, and return on investment for every significant business expenditure," he explains. "It's transformed our decision-making."
Similarly, Westridge Distillery implemented what Martinez calls "whole-business empiricism" – extending measurement beyond production into every business function.
"We now have objective data informing decisions about everything from bottle design to staff scheduling. The result has been significantly improved efficiency and profitability."
Industry observers suggest this evolution toward comprehensive measurement represents a natural maturation process for craft producers.
"The production-focused measurement culture made perfect sense in the industry's early phases," explains Rivera. "Quality and consistency were the primary challenges. But as the market becomes more competitive and complex, businesses need equally sophisticated approaches to non-production decisions."
This evolution doesn't diminish the artistry or passion that defines craft production. Rather, it puts these businesses on more sustainable footing to continue their craft indefinitely.
"The most successful producers we study aren't abandoning their values or craft principles," notes Dr. Chen. "They're simply applying the same empirical mindset that makes them excellent producers to the full spectrum of their business operations."
For James at Riverview Brewing, this broader approach to measurement has been revelatory. His brewery now tracks everything from individual product profitability to staff productivity with the same detail once reserved for brewing logs.
"We still make decisions based on our values and vision," he says, checking another fermentation tank. "But now those decisions are informed by complete data rather than partial information. It turns out that applying our brewing precision to our business operations makes both sides stronger."
As the craft beverage industry continues maturing, this balanced approach to measurement – bridging the paradox between production precision and business insight – may well determine which producers thrive in an increasingly challenging marketplace.
Still thirsting for knowledge?
